Productive Stuff What Has Come From RaceFail
Saturday, 14 March 2009 00:02I'm not keeping up with the full discussion any more, I just don't have the energy. But particularly engaging page titles on Rydra's linkspam, or links that get referred to on my flist as either insightful or faily, I have read. So, of the admittedly restricted and idosyncratic reading I am currently doing, a few that I think are really important.
racism_101 Did I mention this comm? I haven't gone to look at it or do anything with it or read comments because, well, I'm afraid of running across stuff like what is referenced in
Bingo, Mr. Scalzi. BING-O. (With bonus helpful demonstration of advanced FAIL in the comments..)
vito_excalibur documents the bingo being played in Scalzi's comments in response to Mary Anne Mohanraj's teaching posts.
Maybe I'll be a Southron of Harad Someday This is a Racefail, Yay! post. (WAIT! WAIT! In a good way! Or at least, in a 95% fail-free way.)
2ce, a white dude, talks about why RaceFail matters, what are the many issues which it concerns, why the hypertextual nature of it is actually a good thing, why it is the serious discussion of race and racism that That Woman and Scalzi called for, and he begins and ends his discussion by linking to the posts of POC. It's not short, but I think it actually makes one of the better introductions I have seen to RaceFail, the Who Was That Bear Person Again? Period.
Also, there are at least three sorts of people making the tone argument. One is the person just reflectively wishing to be kowtowed to, and inalasahl's Because There Aren't Enough Spoons on the Planet is good enough for those jackasses. They aren't ready to listen to rational argument, and people may take a look at the rational argument to which they object, plus the letter, and have a lightbulb moment.
On the other hand, there are people who are concern trolls through ignorance, who genuinely appear to believe they are offering useful advice no one has ever considered before. (Or that if it has been considered before, it was wrongly rejected.) There are also people who just don't deal well with anger and are sufficiently put off by their initial brush with anger that they don't go to find more conciliatory writings on the same topic. For those people, Jim Hines' discussion of anger may be more appropriate. NB: I have linked to the reply page rather than the page with comments, because the previous post in his LJ re RaceFail was full of fail in his comments, IIRC. I have not read any responses to his post on anger, because I try to avoid sporking myself in the eye.
Last but not least,
exp_horizons / Expanded Horizons is a chromatic realities online zine. Six issues to date, paying market, equally interested in female, queer, genderqueer, and disabled peoples' stories, but, sadly, not erotica.
Bingo, Mr. Scalzi. BING-O. (With bonus helpful demonstration of advanced FAIL in the comments..)
Maybe I'll be a Southron of Harad Someday This is a Racefail, Yay! post. (WAIT! WAIT! In a good way! Or at least, in a 95% fail-free way.)
Also, there are at least three sorts of people making the tone argument. One is the person just reflectively wishing to be kowtowed to, and inalasahl's Because There Aren't Enough Spoons on the Planet is good enough for those jackasses. They aren't ready to listen to rational argument, and people may take a look at the rational argument to which they object, plus the letter, and have a lightbulb moment.
On the other hand, there are people who are concern trolls through ignorance, who genuinely appear to believe they are offering useful advice no one has ever considered before. (Or that if it has been considered before, it was wrongly rejected.) There are also people who just don't deal well with anger and are sufficiently put off by their initial brush with anger that they don't go to find more conciliatory writings on the same topic. For those people, Jim Hines' discussion of anger may be more appropriate. NB: I have linked to the reply page rather than the page with comments, because the previous post in his LJ re RaceFail was full of fail in his comments, IIRC. I have not read any responses to his post on anger, because I try to avoid sporking myself in the eye.
Last but not least,